Most conversations about pricing are conversations about size. In retail, something else decides far more often whether a price works: whether a shopper can do the arithmetic before buying. An offer that only becomes clear at the till is a risk, and shoppers treat it as one.
This guide splits pricing strategy into four parts you can decide separately: your position, the architecture of your prices, how you communicate them, and the mechanics of your promotions. Then there is the part you do not control: the price your competitor puts in front of the same shopper in the same week.
Two sources carry the text. The first is a conversation from our podcast. Laurens Mauquoi, Chief Digital Officer at nexeye, runs marketing and product management for three brands across five countries and more than 800 stores in Europe. On the Reyo podcast 360 Marketing & CRM he explained why his business bets on price transparency instead of percentage discounts. His figures are his statements, not benchmarks. The second is our own market panel of newsletters from German retailers, here the four weeks from 12 October to 8 November 2026. We never name the shops; the point is the pattern, not the sender.
Pricing strategy is not discount strategy
The two terms get used interchangeably and mean different things. A discount strategy answers how far you deviate from the normal price, when, and for whom. A pricing strategy answers what that normal price is and what it tells people about you. Work only on the first question and you optimise the exception while the rule goes unexamined.
Four parts, four decisions:
| Part | The question behind it | How you notice it is missing |
|---|---|---|
| Position | Where do you stand in the market, and against whom? | You justify prices with your costs instead of your place in the market |
| Architecture | How are prices and tiers built across the range? | Every category has its own logic and nobody can explain it |
| Communication | How much of that reaches the inbox, the shop, the shelf? | Shoppers ask what the final price is instead of knowing it |
| Mechanics | What does a promotion actually look like? | Every promotion needs an explanation and the team argues about it |
Discount depth belongs in the fourth part, and even there it is one option among several. How to run it without losing margin is in the guide to discount strategy for e-commerce.
Part 1: position
Position is a decision about the relationship between price and value, not about having the lowest number. Mauquoi describes his brand as value for money and explicitly separates it from discount: quality and fashion first, the price as a pleasant surprise. The 2027 campaign claim says it in one line: "High-quality eyewear, surprisingly affordable."
That it still amounts to price leadership comes from the arithmetic underneath. According to Mauquoi, his business sits around 60 percent below the German market price, which matters most for varifocals and customers on smaller budgets. That is his statement about his market, not a benchmark for yours. The transferable part is the order: set the position first, derive the prices from it, not the other way round.
In practice that means three things:
- Name the set of competitors you are actually up against. Not "the market", but the three to five players your customers genuinely compare you with.
- Decide how much cheaper or dearer you intend to be, as a figure someone can check.
- Write down what justifies the gap. Service, range, advice, speed. If nothing comes to mind, your price is your only argument.
Part 2: architecture
Architecture is the part customers never get explained and feel anyway. At nexeye it is radically simple: every pair of glasses costs essentially the same, with branded frames carrying a small premium of around 69 euros. Anyone walking in knows the sum before they try anything on.
The opposite approach is widespread, and Mauquoi is blunt about it: advertising an entry price that applies to a handful of frames out of thousands. That pulls people into the store who then hear a different number from the one in the ad. The gap is not paid for out of margin, it is paid for out of trust.
An architecture that holds has three properties:
- Few tiers. Three price points are memorable, twelve are not.
- An explainable premium. What you pay more for must be sayable in half a sentence.
- The same logic across categories. If one category does its own maths, that needs a reason the shop floor knows too.
Exceptions are fine when they are deliberate. Mauquoi calls contact lenses a "pricing and volume game": a new category where percentages do appear at launch, with the aim of becoming price leader there too. One reasoned exception does not break an architecture. Twenty unreasoned ones end it.
Part 3: communication
This is where our panel shows how retailers actually talk about price. Across the four weeks from 12 October to 8 November 2026, roughly every second email carries a price reduction. What matters is the form it takes.
A good third of those emails use an "up to" figure, and a gap opens between the two variants: where a fixed percentage appears, the middle of the range sits at 20 percent; where "up to" appears, the number quoted sits at 50 percent. The big number almost always travels in the non-committal form, so the most eye-catching figure in the inbox is the one shoppers can rely on least.
It gets worse one line further up. Of the emails running an "up to" promotion, fewer than three in ten carry that qualifier in the subject line. The percentage stands alone in the preview, and the caveat arrives once the email is open. That buys opens with an expectation the content does not settle.
Then the conditions. Close to half the emails with a reduction bring at least one hurdle: a minimum order value, a code, or a list of exclusions. Each can be sensible on its own. Together they decide whether anyone can work out the final price before the basket reveals it.
Finally, the currency of the message itself. A percent sign appears in about one subject line in five, a concrete euro amount in only about one in fourteen, and across all promotions percentage reductions are roughly five times as common as a fixed money-off amount. Percentages have to be converted and amounts do not. We see what was sent, not how it performed. But the direction is clear: retail communicates in the unit that is convenient internally, not the one understood instantly at the kitchen table.
| Wording | What a shopper can work out | When it still fits |
|---|---|---|
| "20 percent off everything" | the final price, immediately | broad promotions without exclusions |
| "up to 50 percent" | nothing binding | genuine clearance ranges, then with a from-to span |
| "15 euros off orders over 75" | the final price and the threshold | steering basket size |
| "second item free" | the unit price, after one division | multi-buy within the same category |
Part 4: mechanics
Mauquoi's business uses no percentage discounts on glasses at all. The reasoning is not a margin calculation but mental arithmetic from the customer's side: a discount on the second item is worthless if you do not know the price of the first, and the second may well be dearer. "Far too complicated" is his verdict. Instead there are clear, named promotions where the price per item is simply stated.
That gives you a two-minute test for any promotion: can someone who does not know your prices work out what they will pay from the subject line and the first paragraph? If not, the mechanic is too complicated, however good it looks on paper. Which mechanics work without a percent sign is covered in the guide to product bundling examples.
One more thing belongs here. In Germany, advertising a price reduction on goods requires you to state the lowest total price applied in the 30 days before it, under section 11 of the Price Indication Ordinance (as of 13 November 2026, legal text in German; this is not legal advice). So permanent strike-through pricing is not just unconvincing, it is regulatory exposure. In our panel a reference price in the subject line is rare anyway.
The part you do not decide alone
A pricing strategy that ignores the market is a price list. Mauquoi tracks competitor prices continuously and puts the principle like this: "Every retailer should know who their competitors are and what their promotions are. Not to copy them, you should not do that. A strong brand draws its power from its own positioning. Nonetheless we need to understand what the competition is offering."
Three observations are useful for pricing work, and none is the list price alone:
- The depth of the headline promotion. Not the lowest number in the market, but the one your direct competitor goes broad with this week.
- The mechanic behind it. Percentage, fixed amount, free gift or bundle. The mechanic says more about the margin situation than the number does.
- The conditions. Minimum order value, exclusions and run time tell you how serious a promotion is.
It gets genuinely valuable over time. Once you can look up when a competitor opened their big promotion last year and at what depth, you stop planning yours against a hunch. How to set that up is covered in the guide to competitor price monitoring, and the depths common across the market are in the discount benchmark.
Common mistakes
- Big number in the subject line, caveat in the body. That produces opens and disappointment at once.
- Advertising an entry price that applies to almost nothing. The correction arrives in the basket, and it sticks.
- Using percentages where an amount would be clearer. On small baskets, "5 euros saved" lands better than "10 percent".
- Letting every category invent its own pricing logic. What grew internally has to be explained externally, and rarely survives it.
- Treating a discount as the only answer to competitive pressure. Cut the number and you train customers to wait for the next cut.
How Reyo helps
Your half of this work, the costing, the range and the margin, lives in your own systems. The other half is the market your price is read in:
- Competitor monitoring captures competitor promotions with mechanic, depth, conditions and run time, instead of collecting them by hand.
- Analytics shows the development over months, so you test your market position against data rather than impressions.
- The campaign planner puts your promotions next to the market's dates, so your price does not land in the week five competitors go out with the same thing.
- Marketing recommendations condense market movement into next steps for the current week.
The dates for the current quarter are collected in the Q4 guide 2026. For the wider frame, the guide to sales promotion in e-commerce sorts the instruments, and the guide to omnichannel retail explains why the same price has to be the same price online and in store.
Conclusion
A pricing strategy does not come from asking how much discount you can afford. It comes from four decisions: where you stand, how your prices are built, how you say them, and what your promotions look like. The first three cost nothing and work permanently. The fourth costs margin and works briefly.
Our panel shows that the biggest numbers sit where they are least binding, and that the caveat usually arrives only after the open. Communicate so that a shopper can work out the final price in advance and you trade some attention for something that lasts longer.
Want to see the depth and the mechanics your competitors are working with this week? Book a demo.
This article was published on 13 November 2026.